Noose incidents: Foolish pranks or pure hate?
(CNN) — The media spotlight might have shone most intensely on Jena, Louisiana, but a symbol of racial violence has been hung across America lately, spurring anger, resentment and a big question.
Do all the incidents of hanging nooses — many with hateful notes to their intended black audience — belie an ugly truth about race relations in the United States, or are they just stupid pranks by a few foolish, attention-starved people?
Since September, nooses have been found in a Coast Guard office, a suburban New York police station locker room, a North Carolina high school, a Home Depot in New Jersey and on the campus of the University of Maryland.
A Brooklyn, New York, high school principal, who is black, received one in the mail recently, along with a letter that read, white power forever, The New York Times reported. In mid-October, a noose was discovered outside a post office at New York City’s Ground Zero, just days after a noose was hung on the office door of a black Columbia University professor.
Earlier this week, the head of a black mannequin was found hanging from a noose outside a home in Valley Stream, New York, police said. Beneath the noose, on the mannequin’s neck, was a piece of paper with the n-word written on it, said Detective Jeff Schilling of the Nassau County Police Department.
And days before Halloween, a Stratford, Connecticut, woman reluctantly removed from her yard a dark-hued figure hanging from a noose. It was among numerous innocuous lawn decorations, such as ghosts and a plastic grave marker.
It’s unfortunate that now, we’re gonna have to think twice about what we display because someone might be offended, Jennifer Cervero told CNN. Watch people take offense at Halloween displays
Mark Potok of the Southern Poverty Law Center, which tracks hate crimes, said that the apparent increase in noose incidents is, in part, reaction to the news coverage of the Jena 6.
Since September, the SPLC has recorded between 40 and 50 suspected hate crimes involving nooses, one involving two people traveling the road to Jena during the protests in a pickup truck with nooses affixed to the bumper.
Tens of thousands of white people, if not more, feel that the events in Jena were grossly misportrayed by a politically correct media that twisted what was [to them], really, a six-on-one, black-on-white hate crime into an instance of the oppression of black people, Potok said. That accounts, in part, for a backlash.
CNN and other news organizations devoted much time and effort covering the September protests in Jena. Led by black civil rights leaders, thousands of people gathered in the small Louisiana town to protest what they said was the racist treatment of six black high school students who were being charged as adults in the beating of a white high school student.
Racial tensions were already at a boiling point in Jena in September 2006, when three white teens hung nooses from a tree near the local high school. The day before, black students had received permission from school administrators to sit under the tree — a place where white students normally congregated.
The white students were briefly suspended from classes for hanging the nooses, despite the principal’s recommendation they be expelled, according to Donald Washington, U.S. attorney for the Western District of Louisiana. Watch how the noose became an American nightmare
It wasn’t long before the focus on Jena was diverted to other racially charged incidents involving nooses in the country. I would say undoubtedly some of that is 12-year-olds doing the most obnoxious thing they can think of, Potok said.
In early October, a student who recorded a re-enactment of the Jena 6 incident and posted it on the social networking Web site Facebook apologized, saying the video was not intended to make fun of the six black students, according to The News-Star newspaper of Monroe, Louisiana.
The video, recorded by University of Louisiana-Monroe student Kristy Smith, shows students in blackface apparently acting out the beating of the white Jena student.
One of the men in the tape runs onto a beach acting as if he is holding a noose, and three others — covered in river mud — pretend to knock him to the ground, punch and kick him. At least one racial epithet can be heard.
While the Department of Justice doesn’t keep track of noose-specific offenses, the government published a report in 2000 showing an increase of nooses in professional environments.
And The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission says the race-baiting technique still creeps up in professional environments. There have been at least 20 lawsuits involving nooses in the workplace since 2001.
Of the 5,500 racial harassment charge filings in 2006, anecdotal information from EEOC field offices suggests that some involved nooses, but the agency is unable to quantify that data, according to EEOC spokesman David Grinberg.
On Wednesday, seven black workers employed by an Oklahoma-based drilling company won a $290,000 settlement in a discrimination lawsuit which claimed they felt threatened by the display of a noose on a Gulf of Mexico oil rig.
It’s time for corporate America to be more proactive in preventing and eliminating racist behavior, said EEOC Chairwoman Naomi C. Earp. The EEOC intends to make clear that race and color discrimination in the workplace, whether verbal or behavioral, is unacceptable and will not be tolerated.
found here.

D - South Carolina says:
November 1st, 2007 at 4:34 am
The noose is a symbol of death. For it to be used during Halloween it would seem to be the right time to display this decoration and take it as a decoration.
When a fake person is displayed in the noose the body should be colored purple with yellow dots. But, this will still offend someone.
So either way you can’t win. Just don’t put up any decorations for any holidays and let’s just take all the fun out of every child’s holdiay. The children get so few in their lifetime anyway.
Chuck Baker says:
November 1st, 2007 at 8:38 am
I agree that hanging a dummy from a tree at Halloween should not be an offensive thing. It has been a tradition for many years and bears no ill will toward any particular culture in particular.
I also remember that in the TV show The Addams Family, they always pulled a noose to ring for Lurch, the butler. Is that significant as a hate crime?
I myself used to have a noose tied in the strings of my window blinds. It was not symbolic of anything. I just did it as I thought at the time it was kind of neat.
To me, the noose symbolizes just what it has been for many thousands of years, a method of killing someone. Not a black person in particular, but anyone.
However, I draw the line at using the noose as a symbol of racial hatred. Dragging it behind a truck, tying it to a tree where students sit, tying it or leaving it outside the doors of workers of color. These are all very clearly signs of hatred. The perpetrators of these things should be charged with the crime they committed.
We need to differentiate between what is an intentional hate crime, and what is simply an innocuous display.
No, I know I’m not black and yes I know I will never understand what it is to be black. However, I know also that rascism is a two way street and we all display it to a certain level.
It is my hope and prayer we can live together without seeing “some white person” or “some black person” or being afraid of one another just because our skin color is different. We are all one people. There is only the HUMAN race, not the white race, the black race, or any other sub level. We are ONE race. Let’s act like it.
Andrew Shanley says:
November 1st, 2007 at 11:11 am
Hanging is a form of execution which dates back to the Persian Empire thousands of years ago. No one knows just how many people have died because of this method, and certainly no one knows how many of each race, gender or religion. The noose is a symbol of death, so as you read my responce take it for what it’s worth.
My name is Andrew Shanley, I’m a filmmaker who finished a movie called “Hangman” earlier this year. It involves a serial killer who hangs his victims. Now, I produced, directed and worked on this film well before the “Jenna 6″ case erupted.
In the back of my mind I did think about the sesitivity regarding race when making this film. Some actresses who were black and wanted to play roles of victims of the Hangman, I turned them down because of this possibility. Looking back on that, I feel that it was a wise move. However the sudden focus on a noose being a symbol of hate is somewhat disturbing.
I would ask a question to those who believe the noose is a symbol of hate. Why give those people who are ignorant or racialy intolerant a new symbol to use to offend or intimidate? Hitler took the swatstika from buddism, now it’s a symbol of hate. The KKK took the burning cross, now that’s a symbol of hate.
A good way to win over your enemy is to take away what gives him power. Now that there are “NOOSE” incidents around the country we’re all under the belief that it’s somehow racist. Well here’s another factor that CNN and everyone else didn’t count on…
It’s HALLOWEEN! Everyone is going to have some spooky, scary display in front of their yard. And now that it’s over, all those incidents around the country are going to disapear.
In conclusion, as I said earlier the noose is a symbol of death. I’m sure it doesn’t care who’s neck is in it, black, white, christian, jewish, whatever. Hanging is even in the Bible as the form of suicide Judas committed after betraying Jesus. In six months, most people will have forgotten about all this crazyness. My only hope is that people don’t think I’m a racist simply because I made a movie and a very key figure of that film is now a racist symbol, which it is not!
I’ll let you all judge my film for yourself at my website.
www.flipsidefilms.net
Donna Rose says:
November 1st, 2007 at 12:15 pm
Am I alone in thinking that enough is enough? Why is everything that a white person does construed as racial? There have been more White Americans hung by their necks until they died than Black Americans.
Personally I think that “African-Americans” should stop their crying about slavery. They were not there 250 years ago. When their ancestors were brought to America as slaves, were there boatloads of other Africans running over here to bring them back to their Mother Land? NO!
What’s done is done - AND OVER! Blacks, Whites, Asians, and Hispanics are all Americans now. We need to get along as Americans and stop making news because we can’t get along in our own house.
Matt says:
November 1st, 2007 at 12:49 pm
CNN’s story asks if the nooses are harmless pranks, or signs of growing racism. . .it seems to me that there is a third possibility: that blacks could be leaving the nooses themselves, ala the infamous Tawana Brawley, just to stir trouble. I’m not saying all the nooses, but to exclude this possibility would be naive.
hansy says:
November 1st, 2007 at 12:55 pm
Since when did nooses only apply to blacks??? What about the highwaymen that were hanged? The old west? Im confused! I think this is another example of trying to create pity for the poor folks whose ancesters happened to be slaves. There have been slaves all throughout history, in many countries and many cultures, for thousands of years! GET OVER IT ALREADY!!!
Reggie says:
November 1st, 2007 at 1:30 pm
My how times have change, the truth of the matter is, racism will never die as long as the black folks protest any and everything, white America has stood by quietly and watched as black America is now by far the biggest racist and bigots in existence here! The Jena 6 should be charged with hate crimes, if the roles were reversed there wouldn’t even be a question or issue here, although the NAACP would still be marching, protesting and making noise, with your very sad leaders Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson! You should have real leaders such as Bill Cosby and Barrack Obama, but you don’t!
It is acceptable in America to be black and be a racist, and you can also say whatever you want, but if your white, “Oh my God”, you can’t decorate for Halloween, you can’t even mutter any word that even resembles anything that may offend the suddenly super sensitive black people, or do I need to say “African Americans”, give me a break already, enough is enough, this is America where our free speech is suppose to be protected, unless your white! It is time to get back in touch with common sense and reality people, the madness must end and end now, or racial tensions will only get worse, and when white America finally wakes up, it may be too late! Stop all the whining and complaining about everything black America, if you don’t like it, get the hell out, anywhere but here! I don’t see them whining when they pick up their welfare checks and food stamps, and how much of my tax money pays for the prisons where they are the overwhelming majority? The Real Truth
rose says:
November 1st, 2007 at 8:18 pm
If you watch the cnn special you will see why the noose upsets black america so much.
yes other races have been hung as well but the history of the noose in america lies within the lynching of the black race.if you see these images,the noose,shootin,burning alive,castrating of innocent black people then maybe you will understand.a man was almost hung in 2002 for crying outloud!
As for blacks need to forget about slavery-why is okay for the jewish community who suffered horribly to have their slogan be “we must never forget” and no one has a problem with it!
Also a few years ago, a black man was hung and dragged to his death by a truck while they yelled racial slurs at him.
If racism occurs why can’t we speak on it?!why?!Because it makes some whites uncomfortable?!
We don’t ask whites not to remember their family and ancestors.Those who were slaves our are family members,ancestors.We can’t help it if they were enslaved.And we’re supposed to just not ever talk about it or speak on it when racism occurs!?
How dare any of you!!!!!!!!
And we don’t complain all the time but some whites want us to just keep quiet and never say a word!
Sorry that makes you uncomfortable,but that is wrong.
Why don’t you(those of you who say that)get over that.
rose says:
November 1st, 2007 at 8:25 pm
Also-if you don’t like us “complaining” why don’t you get out.I mean the native american were here before your people.So you get out!
And there are more whites on welfare than blacks.
And do not lump all blacks together if one or some support this person or that person.We are not the same person.Just because some white person agrees with George Bush does not mean they all do.
Just because Ted Bundy killed those women or Gaisey or Manson killed those people,that doesn’t mean all white people are like that.
I don’t believe that.But why is that some white people deem us all welfare recipients if one black person is on welfare,or all crooks if one commits a crime.
And no one is saying you can’t have Halloween!
Just like you want people to be “sensitive” to something,why can’t others.It’s not just democracy,or free speech for you you know.Others are allowed to voice to whatever opinion they have.You contradict yourself if you believe otherwise.
That’s rich-go back to Africa-you just prove people right with that kind of statement.
Davis says:
November 2nd, 2007 at 11:32 am
Try getting over Pear Harbor, 911 or the Civil War you ignorant cave man lost. Slavery will not be forgotten because blacks will never be victims to it again. Good luck on judgment day, try passing off you desensitized naive hate filled hearts.
shanna says:
November 2nd, 2007 at 12:11 pm
Swatika should be placed in every jewish lawn by the same people who put up nooses. Let’s see the reaction of the nation then. You people are full of it. You know exactly what you’re doing and to down play it is in the same spirit of hatred that your ancestors portrayed. The same evil spirit in them is still in the descendants. All whtie people are innately evil, lying, rapist, murders.
shanna says:
November 2nd, 2007 at 12:14 pm
your ignorant ancestors also thought there was nothing wrong with killing millions of people. I guess maybe not until your mother , father or child is hanging in one will you understand. The heart of white people is so evil that they don’t even realize the hatred that they have for anyone other than themselves. Oh, no, wait. You people treat each other bad as well. Go figure.
shanna says:
November 2nd, 2007 at 12:16 pm
ITALIANS — you know until blacks came along you were the scum of the earth. I guess that’s why you have no problems with anything that takes the attn off yourselves.
Chuck Baker says:
November 2nd, 2007 at 4:59 pm
Hi Rose, Shanna, and Davis…
Rose, when you said “do not lump all blacks together” because of certain beliefs or support they give, I must caution against the same being done with those of us who are white. I am a white male with a shaved head. Immediately upon that description, what do you see? I know what you see as I have been viewed and judged before ever being known. I have encountered many who are black who look at me and see a white rascist guy. Why? I’ve not even spoken to them yet. And when I do, it’s 50/50 on whether I get a return greeting. And of that, at least half are nervously doing it because they feel like they have too. I think rascism runs heavily both ways. We need to judge people by who they are and not what color they are.